We are currently trapped in the deadest part of the NFL offseason. Practically every bit of free agency is wrapped up, trade season is done (for now), and training camps don’t convene for another few weeks. Outside of the occasional update on rehabbing stars, the NFL is devoid of real news at the moment. Really, it’s an absolutely awful time of the year if you don’t care for baseball.
As a result of this boredom-inducing doldrum of a July, I found myself listening to ESPN’s Fantasy Focus Football podcast today, despite the fact that there’s really nothing to discuss on the topic. I mean, even fantasy draft season won’t start until the end of the month. Nevertheless, as I was tuning in and out of the football ramblings, I caught a statement that truly piqued my interest.
While discussing the disparity between the number one fantasy tight end and the rest of the field, the podcast’s host offhandedly commented on the top tight end’s career by posing a question: “Is Rob Gronkowski already a Hall of Fame tight end?”
It’s an interesting notion (as far as offseason football discussion is concerned) and I couldn’t help but dig into this proposal. If Gronk never played another snap of professional football, would he actually be worthy of enshrinement in Canton alongside the all-time elite at the position?
Now, he’s just 27. This hypothetical scenario is ridiculous unless you’re a perpetual pessimist willing to bet on the non-zero chance that Gronk suffers a career-ending injury. There’s roughly a 99% chance Gronk continues to play at a high level for at least another season or two. All of this taken into account, if you want to stop reading now, I’d understand. But if you’re as bored as I am, please take a moment to ponder this unimportant notion, with my thoughts peppered in to help you develop a more informed opinion.
First, we need to establish the elite class to which we are trying to ascribe Mr. Gronkowski. Currently, only eight tight ends are permanently enshrined in the Pro Football Hall of Fame: Mike Ditka, John Mackey, Jackie Smith, Kellen Winslow, Ozzie Newsome, Dave Casper, Charlie Sanders, and Shannon Sharpe. I’m sure there’s casual fans out there that wouldn’t recognize a couple of those names. Regardless, it’s an exclusive club Gronk’s trying to join.
Amongst the eight current HOF tight ends, there are a combined 43 Pro Bowl appearances and 7 Super Bowl rings. All, save Ozzie Newsome, have graced a Pro Bowl roster at least five times in their careers. Rob Gronkowski already has four appearances to his name. Half of all Hall of Fame tight ends have a Super Bowl ring on their resume. The Gronk already has one ring on his massive finger (and an amusing ESPN commercial as proof). In summation, Gronk clearly has the personal accolades and team accomplishments to measure up with the immortalized elite at his position.
But awards are not the only requirement for enshrinement in Canton. To be a Hall of Famer, one also must boast the career statistics befitting of an all-time great. So let’s see how the NFL’s resident partier stacks up on the stat sheet.
First, let’s look at the statistic that best encapsulates the greatness of Gronk: touchdowns (all statistics provided by pro-football-reference.com). Gronkowski has found his way into the end-zone 66 times in his regular season career, with another 9 TDs in his 10 postseason games.
You know how many Hall of Fame tight ends can match those totals? None.
Shannon Sharpe leads all current Hall of Fame tight ends in the category with 62 regular season TDs. It’s not crazy to say that Gronkowski is the premier end-zone threat in the history of the sport. That’s how prolific Gronk is at finding pay dirt.
Scoring is essential to winning football games (unsurprisingly, Gronkowski’s Patriots have won quite a few games in his career), but there are several other important statistics used to evaluate pass catchers.
For instance, receiving yards are important when evaluating the wholistic value of a position player. Comparing Gronkowski’s 5555 career receiving yards to the Hall of Fame elite helps paint a more complete picture of how Gronk measures up. In this case, Gronkowski only outpaces John Mackey, Dave Casper, and Charlie Sanders in career receiving yards. However, Gronk’s yards per reception outpaces six of the eight HOF tight ends, including the Hall’s current tight end receiving king, Mr. Sharpe. While his career yardage arguably doesn’t equate to Hall of Fame worthiness, the underlying numbers hint that in perhaps as few as two more seasons, Gronk should likely surpass every Hall of Famer, save Sharpe, in career yardage.
Another interesting receiving statistic regarding Gronk: remove Sharpe from the equation, and the young tight end has at least 300 more career playoff yards than every Hall of Famer at the position. I know, opportunity, quarterback differentials, etc., but that’s still one remarkably impressive comparison.
Combine the career receiving stats with his bare-minimum average blocking skills, and Gronkowski already seems like a shoe-in for Hall of Fame induction, with much of his career still to come.
But let’s not discount the knowledge that Gronkowski is currently playing in a much more pass-happy league than his HOF peers, meaning that his statistics may be inflated as a result of increased freedom in the receiving game. How can we quantify this disparity accurately?
Well, we should look no further than two no-doubt future Hall of Famers that have spent the majority of their careers with the same rules in place which Gronk has been bestowed: Tony Gonzalez and Antonio Gates.
A 12x Pro Bowler and, in my mind, the greatest tight end in NFL history, Tony Gonzalez has nearly 3x as many career receiving yards as Gronkowski and also has 45 more touchdowns than the young challenger to his throne. After 17 terrific seasons spread across Kansas City and Atlanta, Tony Gonzalez is the standard for immortality that all future tight ends must be measured against. This comparison was meant to humble young, jubilant Gronkowski, but it’s really unfair to this point.
Instead, take a look at the career of Antonio Gates. Heading into the 2016 season, Gates has eight Pro Bowl appearances to his name, with 10644 receiving yards and 104 touchdowns to boot. However, across nine postseason starts, Gates has found the end zone just once.
As a regular season performer, Gates is well-above Gronkowski, as matters currently stand. However, Gronkowski has a significant advantage when comparing postseason resumes, and one’s accomplishments in the playoffs often hold significant weight when evaluating Hall of Fame candidacies. While Gates would still clearly be selected for enshrinement over his young counterpart, the rift separating the two is not as wide as many may think and should shrink significantly over the course of the 2016 season.
All told, it’s tough to make a judgement for Gronkowski’s Hall of Fame candidacy as things currently stand. Would you consider Heath Miller a HOF-worthy tight end? All variables considered, Miller is probably owner of the most comparable career to current day Gronkowski. In all likelihood, Heath Miller won’t be deemed worthy of a spot in Canton. By extension, I suppose that would mean Gronkowski, as of yet, is still shy of the Hall of Fame.
Again, Rob Gronkowski is just 27 and already compares favorably to a number of Hall of Fame tight ends. To say that he wouldn’t deserve enshrinement in Canton this very second is absurd and not an absolute certainty. Plus, he’s got years to add to his already outstanding resume.
The very idea that Gronkowski’s Hall of Fame candidacy is actually debatable at this stage of his career is the most stunning indicator of his generational talent. The Gronk is incredible and we should all feel fortunate to watch (hopefully) many more seasons of one of the NFL’s premier athletes of all time.
“We now return you to your regularly scheduled NFL withdrawal.”